Older Women in Translation

This month I have been invited to focus on older women in fiction around the world. But there is a problem as there is so little in translation. So what’s the problem? Well, I’ll use the acronym: WYSIWYG pronounced whizzywig.  It stands for what you see is what you get.

When it is applied to people this phrase usually means nothing is hidden. But when it is applied to published works – books, films, art, photographs, adverts etc – it is limiting: what you see is allyou get, and all the wonderful variations in the world are lost.

7 road sign

In my first blog in this series I quoted James Baldwin. I repeat the quotation here. To change the world you need to change the way people see it, he suggests.

The world changes according to the way people see it, and if you alter, even but a millimetre the way people look at reality, then you can change it. [quoted in the TLS by Sarah Ladipo Manyika 28.5.19}

We need to change how people see older women. And that includes adding the way older women are seen in cultures and languages that are not our own.

Here’s Daniel Hahn who is a translator: He was writing about the importance of the work of the translator:

It assumes that just because you’re from Here doesn’t mean you shouldn’t be reading stories from There. That it’s possible to strip a story of its language, wrest it thousands of miles, re-clothe it in a strange new language, and keep its essence intact – because stories can be citizens of the world, just like we can. That just because something is particular doesn’t mean it’s not universal. (A basic principle for all great literature, surely?) That openness to other literatures – and other narratives, and lives, and worlds – doesn’t threaten our own, it strengthens and enlivens it. [From Carrying Across, in The Author, Summer 2017].

The problem of numbers

In the US the problem is sometimes referred to as the 3% problem. In the UK it is more like the 4.5% problem. The problem starts with the small percentage of books in translation that are published every year. There is a problem. But for older women there is an accumulator at work.

This statistic is made worse when you realise that fiction by women is less publicised in reviews than men’s, and there are also fewer women reviewers. See the work of VIDA: Women in Literary Arts for statistics on this, over time, which seem to change very little.

And then generally there is a dearth of books that feature good role models of older women. Something is happening here which is the opposite of amplification. Older women in fiction in translation, both writers and subjects, are at the bottom of the heap. If women in translation are about 30% of that 4.5% I can’t imagine how tiny is the number of books about older women translated and published.

It’s more than a problem of numbers

Elderly Woman Smiling And Dancing

We need to expand our views and understandings of older women.

For example: A friend recently sent me a link to an article that called for the media to stop referring to older women as ‘grannies’. Not all older women are grandmothers. And even those who are may not define themselves primarily in terms of their relationships with their grandchildren. Nor should we be asked to assume that they do. Incidentally it is a sexist term, for the equivalent term is not used for men. They are more likely to be called pensioners. We seem to want to find euphemisms for the word old.

For example: the sweet old lady, quiet, knitting, with a cat, at peace with the world is very strong in the popular imagination in the UK and I have heard older women refer to it as the Mrs Pepperpot version. Many women are angry, political, active, non-knitters. They may be black. They may be lesbians. Some even hate cats. I like Hagar Shipley (The Stone Angel), Tove Jansson’s grandmother (The Summer Book), and Emerence (The Door) because they are feisty. They do things in their own way.

When we were researching our book The New Age of Ageing* we especially enjoyed discovering the project in Sheffield in which women took photographs of themselves that broke conventional representational rules. You can see their work on the Look At Me. Images of Women and Ageing.

If I want to wear a sleeveless top I shall wear a sleeveless top and if my bra bothers ne, I shall bloody take it off. That’s it. I mean there’s got to be a silver lining in everything. The silver lining in old age is that you can do what you like and nobody can tell you any different. [Hermi aged 85. From the Look at Me project.]

Some of the women featured in this month’s series are very transgressive. Others remind us that they have lives that extend back many decades, and the people they used to be are still part of them. I especially like Moon Tiger by Penelope Lively for this reminder.

Celebrate those working against the grain

7 The Storyteller Wm Strang 1911  The Story Teller by William Strange 1911

To change what we see let’s start by celebrating those who promote fiction in translation.

Publishers:often independent, with fiction in translation on their lists: such as And Other Stories, Peirene Press, Pushkin Press, and Quercus.

Prizes: there are several to keep an eye on.

Supportive initiativessuch as English PEN Writers in Translation.

Blogs: biblibio, Global Literature

Events/focus dates

  1. Women in Translation Month Meytal Radzinski has done a great job reviewing the figures for women in translation. #WITMonth is promoted by her on twitter and on her blog: biblibio. She tweets and blogs throughout the year.
  2. International Translation Dayoccurs every year on 30thSeptember to celebrate the work of translators in publishing.

Recognise the translators

I was taught German and a little bit of Russian by George Bird. He also worked as a translator. I was thrilled to pick up and enjoy Death of the Penguinby Andrey Kurkov which my former teacher had translated. Translators are essential in this. We should recognise their work.

You can spread the word too

And here on Global Literatures is what’s up next.

Europe

This is what you have to look forward to in week 2:

The Lady and the Little Fox Furby Violette Leduc. Translated by Derek Colman

The Summer Book  by Tove Jansson. Translated by Thomas Teal

The Doorby  Magda Szabo. Translated by Len Rix

The Little Old Lady who Broke all the Rules by Catharina Ingelman-Sundberg. Translated by Rod Bradbury

[Anyone want to say anything about all these translators being men?]

* The New Age of Ageing: how society needs to change by Caroline Lodge, Eileen Carnell and Marianne Coleman, published by Policy Press (2016).

Written and posted by Caroline Lodge of Bookword

7 thoughts on “Older Women in Translation

  1. I’ve translated a story from Italian in which the protagonist is an elderly female storyteller… trying to get it picked up by a publisher. Not an easy task but I’m not giving up!
    Thanks, Caroline, for drawing attention to older women in translation!

    Like

  2. Read Paper Republic is a page I always recommend when it comes to Chinese literature in translation. It is an initiative of Chinese-to-English translators that publish short story translations online to introduce Chinese authors to publishing houses. They hope that this will lead to full translations being commissioned. Only two of their stories so far are about old women, but they are both very good:
    The vignette “Ying Yang Alley” by Fan Xiaoqing, translated by Helen Wang:
    https://paper-republic.org/pubs/read/ying-yang-alley/
    The melancholy “Piano Twilight” by Chen Cun, translated by Michael Day:
    https://paper-republic.org/pubs/read/piano-twilight/

    Like

  3. A couple from Japan off the top of my head:

    The Little House by Kyoko Nakajima, translated by Ginny Tapley Takemori (me!) and published by Darf, features an elderly narrator looking back on her life as a maid in a family in Tokyo in the run up to WW2.
    https://tonysreadinglist.wordpress.com/2019/08/08/the-little-house-by-kyoko-nakajima-review/

    Inheritance From Mother by Minae Mizumura, translated by Juliet Winters Carpenter, published by Other Press
    https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/31544495-inheritance-from-mother

    Like

Leave a Reply to Lori Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s